Brand Narrative: Why You, and Not the Firm Next Door?
Updated: 3 days ago
A brand narrative is the credibility signal a company sends: the reason to choose it over the alternatives. It is the third of the four signals in the Signalling Framework, and its test is repetition. A good narrative is one a client can say back to a colleague a week after hearing it. If they cannot, it is not yet a narrative, however well written.
Most companies are not short of things to say. They have case studies, credentials, values statements, capability decks and mission statements. What they are short of is a thread: one idea that holds across every service and every part of the business, explains why they belong together, and gives a buyer a reason to choose this company over a competitor who is already known.
Where narrative sits in the framework
The Signalling Framework describes four signals, solved from the inside out:
01 Architecture. What is this, and how do the parts relate? 02 Service clarity. What do you do, and for whom? 03 Brand narrative. Why you, and not the firm next door? 04 The halo effect. What does it feel like before a word is read?
Narrative is the third ring. It depends on both rings inside it. It has to stretch across the structure settled in architecture, and it has to carry the ranked services settled in service clarity. And it sets the brief for the outermost ring, because you cannot decide what a brand should look and feel like until you know what it has to say.
What a narrative is, and what it is not
Narrative is easily confused with three things that sit near it.
What it is | Who it is for | |
Positioning statement | A precise internal definition of who you serve, what you offer and how you differ | The team and anyone making brand decisions |
Tagline | A short line used in marketing | Anyone who sees the brand |
Values | What the company believes and how it behaves | Mainly employees and recruits |
Narrative | The thread that explains why you, which people can repeat | Buyers, referrers and the people they tell |
A positioning statement is usually too precise and too internal to repeat. A tagline is often too short to carry a reason. Values describe the company but rarely give a buyer a reason to choose it. The narrative is the part that does that job, and it can draw on all three.
The test is repetition, not elegance
A narrative that sounds impressive in a pitch but cannot be repeated afterwards has failed at its main task.
This matters because in considered markets, most buying decisions involve people who were not in the first meeting. Your contact goes back and explains you to a colleague, a manager or a board. Whatever they can repeat is what the decision is based on. If the narrative is too complex, too abstract or too long, they will summarise it themselves, usually less well than you would.
So the test of a narrative is not how it sounds when you say it. It is what someone else says a week later.
The strongest narratives do two jobs at once
One half of a strong narrative describes what the client gets. The other half describes what the company is. When those two halves are the same idea seen from different sides, the narrative stops sounding like a claim and starts sounding like a description.
A narrative that only describes the client benefit is marketing. It may be true, but it could be said by any competitor offering a similar benefit.
A narrative that only describes the company is self-regard. It explains why the company is proud of itself, without explaining why a buyer should care.
The thread has to run through both. When it does, the reason to buy and the reason the company exists become the same thing, and that is very hard for a competitor to copy, because it depends on who you actually are.
It has to reach every part of the business
A narrative that works for the core business but not for a division, a sub-brand or a newer service line has not finished its job.
When that happens, there are two possible causes. Either the narrative is too narrow and needs widening, or the architecture decision in the first ring was wrong, and the part that does not fit should sit further from the core than it currently does.
This is one of the main reasons the framework is sequenced. A narrative that will not stretch is often diagnosing a structural problem rather than a writing problem, and rewording it will not fix it. Going back a ring will.
Why narrative matters most one level up
Narrative is the ring that matters most when a company is trying to reach more senior buyers than it currently does.
Relationships at operational and middle-management level are often built on delivery: people have worked together, the work was good, trust exists. At director and board level, decisions are often made by people who have never seen your work. They are choosing between you and a firm that is already known at their level.
Your narrative is the reason to choose you over that firm. Without one, the default choice is the known name.
Signs your narrative is failing
Clients describe you in different ways, or in ways you would not choose.
Your pitch changes depending on who gives it.
You win on capability once people have worked with you, but struggle to win new senior relationships.
Your website says what you do but not why you.
A competitor could use your homepage copy with their own logo and it would still make sense.
Parts of the business need their own explanation because the main story does not reach them.
How to work on it
1. Collect the evidence. How do your best clients describe you? Why did they choose you? What do they say when they refer you? Their words are often closer to the narrative than anything written internally.
2. Find the thread. Look for the idea that connects what clients value with what the company genuinely is. It is usually there already, unspoken.
3. Write it both ways. Once as what the client gets, once as what the company is. If they are not the same idea, keep going.
4. Stretch it. Test it against every part of the architecture and every hero service. Where it does not fit, decide whether to widen the narrative or revisit the structure.
5. Test it by repetition. Tell it to someone outside the company, wait a few days, and ask them to explain you to someone else. Listen to what survives.
What narrative hands to the next ring
A settled narrative gives the outermost ring, the halo effect, its brief. Visual identity, photography, film, motion and every other perceptual signal can now be designed to express something specific, rather than to look good in general. Design commissioned at this point has a brief. Design commissioned before it has only taste.
Next in the series: The halo effect: what your brand says before a word is read
Frequently asked questions
What is a brand narrative?
A brand narrative is the central idea that explains why a buyer should choose a company over the alternatives, in a form people can remember and repeat. In the Signalling Framework it is the credibility signal, the third of four, and its test is whether a client can repeat it to a colleague a week later.
What is the difference between a brand narrative and a positioning statement?
A positioning statement is a precise internal definition of who you serve and how you differ, written for the team. A brand narrative is the outward-facing thread that people can repeat, explaining why you rather than a competitor. The narrative often draws on the positioning, but it is designed to travel.
How do you know if a brand narrative is working?
Ask people outside the company to describe you a few days after hearing it, and listen to what they say. If their description is close to the narrative, it is working. If it varies widely, or sounds like any competitor, it is not.
Why does a narrative need to cover the whole business?
Because a narrative that only works for part of the business leaves the rest unexplained and makes the company look fragmented. If one part cannot be reached by the narrative, that is often a sign the brand architecture needs revisiting rather than the wording.
Why does narrative come before visual identity?
Because you cannot decide what a brand should look and feel like until you know what it has to communicate. Visual design created after the narrative has a clear brief. Visual design created before it is shaped mainly by taste.
The Signalling Framework series
Signal 03: Brand narrative (you are here)
Working with us
Every VMV.STUDIO engagement starts with a Signal Session: a written read of all four signals as they currently stand, what each one is costing, and the order of work that follows.
If people who know your work love it but new senior buyers keep choosing a better-known name, tell us what is not landing.
Comments